A couple of weeks ago, if you remember, I wrote an ode to Arizona’s desert loveliness.
Has the state now betrayed me?
Last Friday, Arizona Governor Jan Brewer signed into being one of the most reactionary, racist laws in recent memory in Arizona. I won’t rehash the details of the “Support Our Law Enforcement and Safe Neighborhoods Act.” Suffice it to say that its illogic is mind-boggling, and the hate and cynicism that fueled its passage astonishing.
Notwithstanding headlines that charitably describe the law as “tough,” there is already talk of boycotts and court challenges from different corners of the country. This law is going to be hard on Scottsdale’s convention industry.
But it’s worth noting that some of the most powerful opposition has come from within Arizona, a state that is as divided as the rest of the country as a whole, over this issue and others. My (many) cousins and relatives in the state have started plastering Facebook with protests, and the sheriff of Pima County (which includes Tucson) has refused to enforce the law, which he calls “disgusting” and “racist.” (There’s a suggestion in Tucson that predates the law: “Why don’t we trade Phoenix for Austin, Texas?” That, they say, would consolidate the best and the worst of the Southwest.)
Arizonans are not the enemy — many of them will, in fact, be victimized by this law. Rather, the battle over bigotry is going to be won with the help of Arizonans — from libertarians to progressives to constitutional conservatives to migrant rights activists. They may have different perspectives on what a fixed immigration system will look like, but they can all agree that curtailing civil rights is a terrible solution. SB 1070 is an exaggeration of the fears that exist, to some degree, in every state in the union (with the possible exception of New Mexico — Borque cousins holler if I’m wrong about that). That makes it a national issue.
Reactionaries and opportunistic populist Arizonan politicians, in their extremism, have laid bare the true dynamics of the immigration debate. And the battle brewing in the Southwest could force a break in the country. Shunning Arizona in the form of a business boycott is one way to show the strength of the opposition to the law. But I’ll also be asking my friends and relatives who say they are “so ashamed to be from Arizona right now” what we outside of the state can do to help and engage politically. They are the ones who will have to fight this law most directly — and the outcome of the fight could affect the entire country.
Finally, make sure you watch Jon Stewart and company’s take.
(HT to NV for the image.)